Does anyone actually think of this as a winking smiley?

To me it's always looked more like a "You're a fucking stupid douchebag, aren't you? " smiley.

Yup. Whenever see that I think arrogant douche.

And the regular smiley, appears more to more of a "OK, I'm smiling because I have no idea what's going on" face.

doesn't look like unsure to me, more like... i can't believe you just said that and it's really awkward in this thread now..

but maybe that's just me

Depends on the context I guess

this is clearly Meatwad.

That is awesome.

Nooooooooo

And doesn't look anything like a person rolling his eyes. Wait...