Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Marijuana Legality
404 Daily: File Found > Community Home > Intellectual Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3
The President
Holland's economic footprint is a wee bit smaller than the US.
B C
QUOTE(The President @ Jul 3 2007, 08:51 AM) *

Holland's economic footprint is a wee bit smaller than the US.

So what factors present only in the much larger population of the US do you foresee as negating the benefits of marijuana legality? In essence, I'm contending that these are not apple and oranges, but rather apples and much smaller apples - so what sets them apart?
Usurper
Size sets them apart, obviously.
B C
QUOTE(Usurper @ Jul 8 2007, 09:54 PM) *

Size sets them apart, obviously.

Canada's even bigger and its lax marijuana laws are not turning it into hell.

Next.
Ænima
QUOTE(B C @ Jul 8 2007, 08:37 PM) *

Canada's even bigger and its lax marijuana laws are not turning it into hell.

Next.


But thats because nothing happens in Canada. Nothing. At all. Ever.
Kefka
QUOTE(Ænima @ Jul 23 2007, 02:05 PM) *

But thats because nothing happens in Canada. Nothing. At all. Ever.

...because everybody can smoke weed? smile.gif
Frankie G
Here is something I found, thought it was interesting. I don't have much else to add to this.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,291043,00.html
Chrono
I'd like to contest that article on the grounds that it's FoxNEWS.
Akuma
QUOTE(Bolt @ Dec 16 2006, 05:44 AM) *

I, for one, completely agree with igotit4cheap. Maybe not with the way he presented his arguments, but if I get the essence of what he's saying, and I think I do, it goes something like this:

Marijuana is a drug with psychedelic properties, and it induces a different mindset which is mostly incompatible with the 'sober' mindset. Neither better nor worse, just different. But these differences create fractures, binaries in society, which erode our stability--look at the endless war between the right and the left, causing heated debates and discord in our country. If marijuana is legalized, the war between pot smokers and non-pot smokers would be just as divisive.

Most of the pro-legalization posters in this topic smoke weed, and obviously feel that it is a good idea. I do not, and though I think legalization is ultimately ideal, I think that it would only serve to create more fractures and binaries in society, and since pro/anti marijuana legalization does mostly run along the same poles as the right/left ones, it would create internal discord and conflict beyond what we are already facing in these contentious times.

Basically, marijuana legalization is not as simple as 'it has less health risks than alcohol,' and our country just is not ready for the political, ethical, and philosophical baggage that comes with its approval, not to mention the fallout that would ensue from the government admitting to decades of propaganda, lies, inprisonment, wasted tax dollars, wasted man-hours. Not to mention that marijuana impairs the ability to perform many work-related activities at a rate far beyond anything alcohol can provide, in regards to its lingering effects post-consumption. Not to mention that there is no easy way to create a line of demarcation for 'highness,' apply it to driving while intoxicated, and provide a means of measurement for police officers the nation over. Not to mention that marijuana is demotivating for many, running in opposition to the drive for excellence we hold as one of our national ideals. Not to mention that there is a false assumption made by most weed advocates, that the government is okay with the legality of alcohol, rather than that the prohibition of alcohol simply did not work in any way, while the prohibition of marijuana, while inefficient, is still working on a fundamental level. Not to mention that the majority of people want it to remain illegal, and that there is no reason for the government to attempt to sway them otherwise.

(if you want to smoke it, smoke it. you're safe in your own home, and alcohol consumption is banned in most public places, so it serves to reason that marijuana consumption would be as well, anyway. so what's the difference? you can't get high in bars? hop off.)


I shall attempt an answer.

Are you sure it'd be that damaging to society? I know people have different views about alcohol, but I am yet to meet someone who actually believes it should be illegal. I'm sure they exist but they must be a minority. I don't think it would become a societal fracture. Drinking is more dangerous and disruptive to people's health and lifestyles than pot right now and I don't see a major split in societal opinion on whether booze should be legal or not.

As for it damaging the economy, well change usually makes things worse for a while until it gets better. Perhaps part of the economy may be damaged, but then others may get stronger, err maybe. It's been a while since college and when I studied economics.

Your point on cops being able to have a sobriety test for pot is very good and has made me think. A blood test is too far of course.

I think that things would be good if those who are staunchly pro legalization could come up with legitimate plans on how to integrate pot into our society safely and relatively smoothly, things may be easier in terms of legalization.

The argument of health risks is fairly simple in my view. My Mother who is a registered nurse (a high grade one) has herself admitted she would rather I smoked pot on a regular basis (in moderation) than drinking or smoking tobacco. I have drank a lot in the past and I have smoked a fair amount too. Drinking is the only one I have EVER felt ill-effect from either the same day or afterwards. I'm not a pothead (I've smoked twice in the last FIVE years) and I'm no longer a drunkard either. I just honestly think that pot should be legal. I would smoke on a friday night instead of drinking and I know my head would feel much better come Saturday morning.

I hope I haven't given away the fact that I'm debating above my station here......
Zoho Gorganzola
QUOTE(Frankie G @ Jul 27 2007, 12:21 AM) *

Here is something I found, thought it was interesting. I don't have much else to add to this.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,291043,00.html


I recall reading a story that debunked those numbers as being taken out of proportion. The fact is, it increases your chances by like a percentage point, from like 2% to 3% (40% of 2% =~ 1%, 1% + 2% = 3%, see the math now) If you skew the numbers the same way on alcohol, it's apparently something like an 800% increase. Just another awesome scare story from fox news.
brandotron
My main argument for anyone who believes in a God (as much of our government claims to): Marijuana is a plant that grows naturally; it has existed as long as human beings, likely longer. Do you honestly believe that we as humans have the wisdom, let alone the authority, to say that God was wrong in creating this plant? Marijuana was God's little "oops"?
Zoho Gorganzola
QUOTE(brandotron @ Aug 25 2007, 06:31 PM) *

My main argument for anyone who believes in a God (as much of our government claims to): Marijuana is a plant that grows naturally; it has existed as long as human beings, likely longer. Do you honestly believe that we as humans have the wisdom, let alone the authority, to say that God was wrong in creating this plant? Marijuana was God's little "oops"?


Well a religious person could counter that argument with the garden of eden story, citing that drugs are the apple of knowledge of our time. Not the greatest analogy I know, but leaps of faith aren't uncommon in religious debates. Plus if you want to cite it as a "bad plant" that was an "oops" you could also cite the huge amount of edible looking but decidedly deadly plants that exist all over the planet.
PA.
If God existed and didn't want us to smoke it then we wouldn't be able to, cause how could you go against the will of an omnipotent being?
Paraphen
QUOTE(Nickolay @ Aug 27 2007, 02:40 PM) *

If God existed and didn't want us to smoke it then we wouldn't be able to, cause how could you go against the will of an omnipotent being?


Free Will. God made us in his image because he loved us, but then one person fucks up, so now everybody spends the rest of their life living in a world full of awesome stuff that they're not allowed to do or they go to hell.

I guess God's a dick or something
brandotron
yeah seriously
PA.
QUOTE(Paraphen @ Aug 27 2007, 08:36 PM) *

Free Will. God made us in his image because he loved us, but then one person fucks up, so now everybody spends the rest of their life living in a world full of awesome stuff that they're not allowed to do or they go to hell.

Oh yeah. Well, good thing he'll forgive all my sins in the end.
LifeofX
QUOTE(brandotron @ Aug 25 2007, 06:31 PM) *

My main argument for anyone who believes in a God (as much of our government claims to): Marijuana is a plant that grows naturally; it has existed as long as human beings, likely longer. Do you honestly believe that we as humans have the wisdom, let alone the authority, to say that God was wrong in creating this plant? Marijuana was God's little "oops"?


That is something I truly believe in.

I love presenting that argument to my hardcore Christian friends and watch them fumble.
Poopington
QUOTE(LifeofX @ Sep 7 2007, 12:48 PM) *

That is something I truly believe in.

I love presenting that argument to my hardcore Christian friends and watch them fumble.

Really? The thing I would've said immediately is exactly what Paraphen did. Well, the first thing: free will. The rest I don't really agree with.

Just because God created something that doesn't mean we have to do it or make use of it. Hell, He created the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and gave us explicit instructions to leave it alone. If there weren't vices to tempt us being good wouldn't be anything special. Adam and Eve were sinless, until that point, but they were also basically just complacent children. I guess a bunch of potheads would probably take me saying that and try to claim that weed just wakes you up, mannnnnnnnnn.
LifeofX
Well you have to start going further in to the bible after the initial argument. There is nothing in the bible that prohibits marijuana use.
brandotron
QUOTE(Poopington @ Sep 7 2007, 04:23 PM) *

Really? The thing I would've said immediately is exactly what Paraphen did. Well, the first thing: free will. The rest I don't really agree with.

Just because God created something that doesn't mean we have to do it or make use of it. Hell, He created the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and gave us explicit instructions to leave it alone. If there weren't vices to tempt us being good wouldn't be anything special. Adam and Eve were sinless, until that point, but they were also basically just complacent children. I guess a bunch of potheads would probably take me saying that and try to claim that weed just wakes you up, mannnnnnnnnn.

But can you ever imagine yourself smoking a joint and then saying "Oh shit, we're naked, Eve. I had no idea. We'd better cover our genitals."? naughty17hs.gif
Zoho Gorganzola
QUOTE(brandotron @ Sep 7 2007, 04:45 PM) *

But can you ever imagine yourself smoking a joint and then saying "Oh shit, we're naked, Eve. I had no idea. We'd better cover our genitals."? naughty17hs.gif


no, i imagine it'd be more like "Eve... I... I forget, I'm gonna go find something to eat"
Paraphen
QUOTE(Poopington @ Sep 7 2007, 03:23 PM) *

Really? The thing I would've said immediately is exactly what Paraphen did. Well, the first thing: free will. The rest I don't really agree with.

Just because God created something that doesn't mean we have to do it or make use of it. Hell, He created the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and gave us explicit instructions to leave it alone. If there weren't vices to tempt us being good wouldn't be anything special. Adam and Eve were sinless, until that point, but they were also basically just complacent children. I guess a bunch of potheads would probably take me saying that and try to claim that weed just wakes you up, mannnnnnnnnn.



You. . . you do realize that I didn't really buy any of what I wrote there, right? I mean, I was playing devil's advocate I guess, in that that's how you'd explain it coming from that point of view, but I have a hard time understanding why any people are religious, at all, much less religious like that.
Master Bob
QUOTE(Paraphen @ Sep 8 2007, 05:13 AM) *
You. . . you do realize that I didn't really buy any of what I wrote there, right? I mean, I was playing devil's advocate I guess, in that that's how you'd explain it coming from that point of view, but I have a hard time understanding why any people are religious, at all, much less religious like that.
WIN!
Poopington
QUOTE(Paraphen @ Sep 8 2007, 02:13 AM) *

You. . . you do realize that I didn't really buy any of what I wrote there, right? I mean, I was playing devil's advocate I guess, in that that's how you'd explain it coming from that point of view, but I have a hard time understanding why any people are religious, at all, much less religious like that.

Well, yeah. You used the biggest misconception out there about Christianity, and probably all religions, so I was pretty sure that was the case.
Paraphen
which misconception?
Poopington
That if you do bad stuff you go to hell, and if you do good stuff you go to heaven. At least that's what I got out of it, but looking back you didn't say it explicitly.
Master Bob
QUOTE(Poopington @ Sep 9 2007, 06:51 PM) *
That if you do bad stuff you go to hell, and if you do good stuff you go to heaven. At least that's what I got out of it, but looking back you didn't say it explicitly.
That's a misconception?
Paraphen
QUOTE(Poopington @ Sep 9 2007, 05:51 PM) *

That if you do bad stuff you go to hell, and if you do good stuff you go to heaven. At least that's what I got out of it, but looking back you didn't say it explicitly.


Gotcha. I mean, that is how it works in any christian religion I know of, but if you're repentant then god forgives you and whatnot.
B C
I have no idea why religion got into this.

I must say this: The "Vice" counterpoint does not stand up. ALL vices are human-made. NONE are natural. Marijuana is entirely natural - simply eating it will give you a buzz.

So really, it would have to be a mistake by God.
Poopington
I...don't follow.

Marijuana's existence is natural, but that doesn't mean that it's natural for people to smoke it or eat it in large amounts.


I don't know that I've ever heard of smoking pot being a sin, though (not that I'm surprised to hear that some people call it one). I don't think it's a sin to do any drug, but if you're doing that and neglecting the shit you should be doing instead, that's sinful.
Da Bears
QUOTE(Poopington @ Oct 11 2007, 10:29 PM) *

I...don't follow.

Marijuana's existence is natural, but that doesn't mean that it's natural for people to smoke it or eat it in large amounts.
I don't know that I've ever heard of smoking pot being a sin, though (not that I'm surprised to hear that some people call it one). I don't think it's a sin to do any drug, but if you're doing that and neglecting the shit you should be doing instead, that's sinful.

Agree.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.